PREP - Professional Enhancement Programs of the MAA



 

Exploring Linear Algebra with Maple

A PREP Workshop

AIM log - Thursday June 30, 10:00 am - 11:30 am

9:54 AM
Russell Blyth: Ready to join the chat?
Mike May: Yes
Marius Buliga: hi
9:55 AM
Parviz Khalili: Good morning all
Tepper Gill: hi, whats the url
Mike May: rtsp://165.134.240.35/LA050630am1.sdp
Harry Mills: Checking my presence.
Harry Mills: OK. I'm here.
Mike May: Same VNC address
Joyce Quella has joined this chat.
Derrick Head: Please resend an invitation to David Thomas
Mike May: Sound and video up
10:00 AM
John Boncek has joined this chat.
John Boncek: good morning
Leah Wrenn Berman: thanks
Harry Mills: Hugh: My attempt to reply to your e-mail failed.
Harry Mills: Hi Regina. Nice work.
Luz DeAlba has joined this chat.
Russell Blyth: HM: email?
Regina Souza: hi
Tepper Gill: I need the am url for qt
Mike May: rtsp://165.134.240.35/LA050630am1.sdp
Hugh Sanders: I'm in.
Regina Souza: I had this big insight: "Maybe I should try the help command' 
Well, it solved my problem (what rookies get stuck at!)
Tepper Gill: ok, Iam in
Russell Blyth: anyone need video?
Harry Mills: No sound, as yet.
Joyce Quella: No sound
Christian Hellings: I have sound.
Russell Blyth: restart QT
Todd Ashby: I have sound
Suzanne Riehl: sound is good here
Russell Blyth: if no sound
Hugh Sanders: Sound is OK.
Dorothy Zeiser: I have sound
Michael Siddoway: Sound good here
Luz DeAlba: All OK here!
Regina Souza: not found - I'll try again
Harry Mills: Sound OK.
John Boncek: Certainly, you may go through the worksheet.
10:05 AM
Regina Souza: got it
Harry Mills: Russell: What's your "Email?" question about?
Dennis Keeler has joined this chat.
Harry Mills: It was only about sending e-mail to Hugh. It was kicked back 
unsent.
Todd Ashby: were these worksheets sent to us via email?
Mike May: no
Mike May: with permission, we'll post them later
Todd Ashby: ok
Mike May: (Permission is now sought from the authors)
John Boncek: Mike = you may post mine. Suggestions/improvements 
welcome!
Mike May: David - please narrate as you see fit
Mike May: applies to each (set of) authors
Suzanne Riehl: You can post mine.
Mike May: if you have a worksheet to send, please ask me to invite you to a 
private chat so we can get the file via chat
10:10 AM
Mike May: That seems to work well
David Huckaby: Ok! Good tip for the first revision. 
Mike May: noting these are all *first* drafts - darn good ones
David Huckaby: Mine had a horizontal axis, but no vertical axis.
Regina Souza: Could you comment on the difference between plots and 
plottools? My code for arrow did not work because I had both packages loaded, 
and it wanted in the syntax for plottools
David Huckaby: Yours seems to have neither.
David Huckaby: regina2005mt, I had the same problem!
Mike May: did you code in 9.5 or 10?
David Huckaby: I just didn't load plottools.
Regina Souza: in 10
David Huckaby: I coded in 9.5.
Harry Mills: sound cut out.
Mike May: we're running in 10, that might explain the different appearance of 
this graph
Mike May: anyone else on sound?
10:15 AM
Suzanne Riehl: I still have sound
Harry Mills: Sound back.
Mike May: OK
Harry Mills: Had to re-open QT. Russell's link defaulted to realplayer.
Mike May: Ah - that would do it - don't click on the link, copy and paste only
Harry Mills: Thx, Mike.
Mike May: (just to be confusing, "Mike" is Russell right now  )
David Huckaby: That part of the code needs revision for the general case.
Harry Mills: The linear combo embedded in the text explanation. Can't you 
highlight it and click on Math button? If so, won't it look "better?"
David Huckaby: Not good practice, eh?
David Huckaby: Harry, what is the math button?
Mike May: is fine for first draft - good work for a day or two of warning
10:20 AM
David Huckaby: Harry, are you using 10 or 9.5?
Harry Mills: David: Upper left of Maple window. There're two buttons side=by-
side: Text and Math
Harry Mills: David: Don't sweat my teeny tiny comments. P.S. Mike's giving 
you a better explanation orally right now.
Mike May: change to next video am2
David Huckaby: Harry: I'll take all the help I can get! 
Mike May: up
Harry Mills: I'm using v10, David. And your work is just fine!
David Huckaby: Thanks. 
Harry Mills: I really like the renderings of scalar multiples of the vectors in 
different colors, so students can SEE what's going on.
Mike May: yes, that's nice
David Huckaby: That random stuff is of course all from you guys (and other 
participants noting what a great idea that is).
Harry Mills: Using different line thicknesses ensures that you can see all of 
'em, too. nice.
10:25 AM
David Huckaby: Yeah, but sometimes all the arrows show up, and 
sometimes some are obscured. Don't know why.
Harry Mills: David: It probably relates to the order in which you call them. I 
suspect if you plot the "smaller multiples" last, they'll superimpose on the larger. 
Using a greater thickness on the "larger/longer" ones
Dorothy Zeiser has left this chat.
David Huckaby: Ah!
David Huckaby: Harry: The problem was with the vectors that end up in 
exactly the same place. Even plotting the thinker ones first didn't work.
David Thomas: What is difference between a list and a set?
David Huckaby: But Mike's method (using the list rather than the set) seems 
to work well.
Mike May: A set is not ordered
David Thomas: Coding wise?
Mike May: {} for set
Mike May: [] for list
Mike May: <> for vector
10:30 AM
David Huckaby: Thanks, everyone. 
Mike May: Thanks for going first!
Suzanne Riehl: This is REALLY rough!
Suzanne Riehl: I didn't get to the plotting.
Mike May: that's ok
Suzanne Riehl: If your call the procedure with [0,0], it works.
Suzanne Riehl: I didn't hear your instructions, RB
Suzanne Riehl: I'm testing the procedure. If you use [0,0] instead of [5/7, 0], 
the procedure works.
10:35 AM
Regina Souza: I don't get the notation: it seems we are adding a number to a 
pair...
Todd Ashby: David: How long to create your workseet?
David Huckaby: I actually did it yesterday evening.
Dorothy Zeiser has joined this chat.
Suzanne Riehl: I also tried using evalf([x1,y1], 3) as the last line of the 
procedure -- it returned a decimal but using that output the next time still caused 
problems.
David Huckaby: In fact, I had a first version in which I used row reduction 
rather than colspace, nullspace commands.
David Huckaby: And the computer froze and lost it!
Todd Ashby: Thanks.
David Huckaby: No problem. 
10:40 AM
Mike May: SR - right now you're trying to get the sub thing working, right, how 
to iterate?
Mike May: I really like the idea for this worksheet
Suzanne Riehl: Yes -- once the procedure works, then a loop will produce 10 
or 20 points to plot.
Mike May: yes
David Huckaby: Todd: One more thing. If you haven't started yet (or even if 
you have), you might consider working off one or more of Mike and Russell's 
worksheets. I used theirs as a template. Otherwise, it would have taken *much* 
longer.
10:45 AM
John Boncek: qrsvd: I agree. I found THAT out yesterday. 
Todd Ashby: understand.
Suzanne Riehl: Yes. the solution goes to 1,2
Mike May: changing tapes
Mike May: video off
Mike May: am3 coming up
Regina Souza: neat! Very instructive also in how to attempt to debug (not that 
I can see me operating at that level very soon)
Mike May: video should be up
Suzanne Riehl: Can you also plot the two equations?
10:50 AM
Suzanne Riehl: No -- method won't always work. Text book also shows points 
generated connected by dashed lines.
David Thomas: How did you get the return without moving to the next >?
John Boncek: in maple 8, you hold down the shift key and hit enter
Regina Souza: y from -5 to 5 also?
10:55 AM
Regina Souza: so that the y values will fit?
Suzanne Riehl: This is fun ... but it might be better to move on to next 
worksheet.
David Thomas: missing comma
John Boncek: This is a great worksheet.
Suzanne Riehl: Thanks for the help!
Regina Souza: why the view command did not work?
Steve Prothero: It might be nice to have a non-convergent example ready for 
students to try
Regina Souza: 
Steve Prothero: I didn't mean you/now I was suggesting that the prof be ready 
when using the sheet
11:00 AM
Parviz Khalili: This is a project that I gave my students
John Boncek: We have a "Computing for Mathematics" course -- this 
worksheet would be a great exercise to show what Maple can do.
Suzanne Riehl: The example the text has for divergence is x - y = 1 and 2x+y 
= 5, initial guess (0,0).
Parviz Khalili: This basically solves a least square problem.
Parviz Khalili: We solve AX=B with the least square method
Parviz Khalili: The next piece is the cubicfit
David Huckaby: That's really cool putting them on the same graph.
11:05 AM
Parviz Khalili: The next is sixth order fit
John Boncek: Nice graphic.
Parviz Khalili: That woild be nice
Mike May: video changing
Mike May: am4
11:10 AM
Mike May: up
Mike May: not up
Mike May: sorry
Mike May: now up
Mike May: any other comments/questions?
Parviz Khalili: That is more efficiet
Mike May: nice worksheet!
Parviz Khalili: I should have added more text
Mike May: PK and DH can we put your w/sheets on the web site?
Mike May: it's great for a short time
Parviz Khalili: Sure you can. Feel free to add text to it if you want
David Huckaby: As long as it's clear that it's just a first draft. 
John Boncek: my audio is in and out, so I might not catch everything. I see this 
as being a supplemental lecture that I can post online.
Harry Mills: Yes. This disc. relates to the use of "long" variable names. A, A1, 
B, B3, etc. aren't as transparent to the student as, for instance, 
BigMatrixThatDoesNeatThings
11:15 AM
John Boncek: Mike: I use BIG type on my machine too
Harry Mills: Careful about the use of "%". It can get you in trouble, because it's 
the LAST thing Maple executed, and not necessarily the line above.
John Boncek: Right -- I knew that!
Harry Mills: Heh.
John Boncek: John's Law: Don't Write Worksheets after Midnight.
Harry Mills: yes, it's useful. But students tend not to re-execute the line above 
in its appropriate context, and then wonder what's happening.
Harry Mills: It's a great way for an instructor to convince students that the 
software prefers the instructor over anyone else.
11:20 AM
Harry Mills: Same code. Works for me, but not for you. HA!
Regina Souza: I use !!! quite often (just in case)
John Boncek: I was thinking about starting in the middle. Hence the restart 
commands
Harry Mills: Now that I have a reasonably fast computer, I use !!! a lot more 
than I used to
John Boncek: That's the next draft -- I didn't get the graphics done!
11:25 AM
John Boncek: right
John Boncek: "a basis, but with redundancy"
Harry Mills: John: Very nice work. EVERYONE's work so far looks quite good. 
I would that I had done more mathematics in mine.
John Boncek: Signal processing!
Harry Mills: Mine'll take about 30 seconds to plumb.
Harry Mills: Not much there, other than some plotting play that's not very 
fundamental.
John Boncek: "Frame"-work. 
Suzanne Riehl: Is there a good place to learn the differences between "subs" 
"evalf" ...
John Boncek: These sheets are great. I have garnered several ideas that I 
think will be useful
Harry Mills: Where's the "Save" and "Load" worksheet? (Its name, i.e.)
Todd Ashby: Very nice, guys!
Leah Wrenn Berman: russell, you're very faint...
Tepper Gill: is there a simple proceedure to sum n (unknown) vectors
Leah Wrenn Berman: is there a way to convert decimals to 
integers??
Harry Mills: subs is symbolic, i.e.
Harry Mills: You had a lengthy procedure that you saved and then loaded.
Harry Mills: Day 1, I believe.
11:30 AM
Michael Siddoway: I'm having difficulty drawing figures like your "Big M." A 
simple <0,0>, <0,1>,  triangle won't connect points.
Harry Mills: Homework 1
Harry Mills: hw1.mw, IIRC.
Harry Mills: Thx.
Harry Mills: assign1.mw
Michael Siddoway: that is <1/2, sqrt(3)/2>
Harry Mills: I may have something nice for you after lunch.
Suzanne Riehl: Does "help" have a place to help you choose the correct 
command? I'm still in the learning mode -- I won't remember the details of 
commands. I haven't found "help" helpful.
Leah Wrenn Berman: are you in the help browser?
Michael Siddoway: OK!
Harry Mills: Suzanne: Right-clicking on the command line, I believe.
Tepper Gill has left this chat.
Hugh Sanders: Regina,
Harry Mills: No promises. Thx, gents.
Regina Souza: yes
Frank Rooney has left this chat.
Michael Siddoway: That did it. Thanks
Dorothy Zeiser has left this chat.
Harry Mills: Off to lunch (steam-cleaning carpet in the in-betweens)
Mike May: OK
David Huckaby: Thanks again. 
David Huckaby has left this chat.
Michael Siddoway: In R^3 does this work?
Hugh Sanders: Regina, I'll try to get what I was doing for Part 6 done between 
now and before the next session.
Todd Ashby has left this chat.
Derrick Head has left this chat.
David Thomas has left this chat.
Mike May: quit video
Mike May: bye for now
Harry Mills: I see it in assign1 on VNC. Thanks, guys.
Steve Prothero: see y'all this pm
Leah Wrenn Berman has left this chat.
Lynne Doty has left this chat.
Michael Siddoway: Thanks for a great morning
Regina Souza: ok - I'll try to initiate private chat before the pm section
Dennis Keeler has left this chat.
Parviz Khalili has left this chat.
Steve Prothero has left this chat.
Harry Mills: *bye 4 now*
Mike May: ok
Regina Souza has left this chat.
Harry Mills has left this chat.
Luz DeAlba has left this chat.
Suzanne Riehl: I'm not sure which help I used. Several times, though, "help 
on context" was not available.
11:35 AM
Hugh Sanders has left this chat.
Suzanne Riehl has left this chat.
Michael Siddoway has left this chat.
Christian Hellings has left this chat.
11:40 AM
Matt Goeke has left this chat.
Marius Buliga has left this chat.
Joyce Quella has left this chat.

Back to Home Page
 
 

This PREP workshop is made possible by the NSF grant DUE: 0341481